The end of the nine weeks is here. Work has been turned in and graded. But what if a student's average doesn't fit what they have accomplished? Should a teacher adjust it to reflect what the student has earned? Or should it be the result of vocabulary quizzes on Quia, Study Island, and objective scores on writing assignments?
Student #1
He has given everything he can possibly give to be successful. He started the year hating to read. Now, he reads almost every night at home. He pays attention in class and does his best on every assignment. He asks for help if he doesn't understand. He has turned in every assignment. Low Study Island scores have been a big detriment to his grade. Although his grades reflect his ability, his growth should earn him an A+.
Student #2
She is the model for all students. Her attitude and work ethic is unbelievable. She has always struggled finishing books. This nine weeks she has finished three of the last four she started. The book she quit was a bad selection, she recognized that, and found a better book. Her writing has consistently improved all year. Her blog posts have become more detailed and cleaner. Poor vocabulary quiz grades have lowered her score.
Student #3
The work he turns in is not close to his best. He completes assignments quickly, with the main idea being just to get them done. He is a pretty good student so his grades are good. He has not shown much growth, but does OK because school comes fairly easy to him.
Student #4
His attitude stinks. He has turned in most assignments, but not all. His grade is poor and does not reflect his ability at all. He should be on the honor roll but isn't due to lack of effort. As a reader, he is able to do high quality work. Even though he has a low grade, his ability is in the B range.
What grades did these students earn? What grades do they deserve? Are they the same?
Should grades be solely based on achievement? Or should a student's effort and attitude be part of the grade? Should improvement matter? Should missing assignments count even if a students has mastered the objective? Or should all grades be based on results of classwork and quizzes? Should students receive a class participation grade that reflects their in class involvement and work ethic?
What if the teacher knows with absolute certainty that a grade does not reflect a student's output for the grading period? Should the teacher adjust the grade accordingly?
Image from http://feeds.feedburner.com/legalgeekery